Ohio State is in the process of revising websites and program materials to accurately reflect compliance with the law. While this work occurs, language referencing protected class status or other activities prohibited by Ohio Senate Bill 1 may still appear in some places. However, all programs and activities are being administered in compliance with federal and state law.

 Teaching and Learning Resource Center

Effective Online Discussion Questions

Online course discussion is an excellent opportunity for teaching and prompting critical thinking. By presenting challenging open-ended questions, you can engage in a sort of asynchronous Socratic questioning with your students. 

Use the following framework to structure your discussion questions or prompts. 

  • Provide a setup. Present a statement, observation, or scenario that requires students to reexamine or apply what they're learning.   
  • Ask students to commit.  Ask a specific question, one that won't have an obvious right answer, likely in one of the following categories. 
    • Personal reflections: “What do you think about ___?” “How do you feel about ___?” 
    • Past experiences: “In the past, how have you responded when ___?” “Have you ever had an experience where ___?” 
    • Rational conclusions: “What conclusion do you draw from ___|?” “Of ___, ___, or ___, which choice makes the most sense given ___?” 
    • Process or order: “How would you go about ___?” “In what order would you ___?” 
    • Guesses or estimates: “What would you do if ___?” “What might have happened if ___?” 
    • Superlatives: “What is the worst approach to ___?” “What is the most appropriate ___?”  
  • Ask students to defend their commitments.  Give students clear directions for defending or explaining their responses. 
    • "Why?"  
    • "Why or why not?" 
    • "Explain your reasoning." 
    • "Defend your response through one of the theoretical frameworks in this week's reading."
    • "Explain your response using data from this week's field observations." 

See also: 

MacKnight, C. B. (2000). Teaching Critical Thinking through Online Discussions. Educause Quarterly, 23 (4), 38–41.  

Murchú , D. Ó., & Muirhead, B. (2005). Insights into Promoting Critical Thinking in Online Classes. International Journal of Instructional Technology.